Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s insistence on achieving “total victory” over Hamas in Gaza has sparked controversy within his own government, as Defense Minister Yoav Gallant recently criticized the slogan as “nonsense.” This internal rift exposes deep divisions in Israel over the handling of the ongoing conflict, now in its 11th month.
Netanyahu has repeatedly vowed to dismantle Hamas’s military and governing capabilities in Gaza, framing it as the only path to secure Israel’s future and recover the hostages held by the militant group. However, Gallant, a senior figure in Netanyahu’s Likud party and a former military general, reportedly told members of the Israeli Parliament’s foreign affairs and defense committee that the prime minister’s goal was unrealistic and counterproductive.
In a strong rebuke, Netanyahu’s office accused Gallant of undermining Israel’s position and harming the chances of reaching a deal to release hostages. “When Gallant adopts the anti-Israel narrative, he harms the chances of reaching a hostage release deal,” the statement read. Netanyahu insisted that “total victory,” defined as the complete eradication of Hamas’s military and governing presence, was the only acceptable outcome.
This disagreement comes at a crucial time, as Israel braces for potential retaliation from Iran and Hezbollah, even as international diplomatic efforts intensify to broker a cease-fire and prevent a broader regional war. Netanyahu’s government, which has leaned increasingly right-wing after the departure of centrist politicians, has been deeply divided on how to balance military objectives with the pressing need to secure the safe return of hostages.
Gallant, often seen as a moderating voice within Netanyahu’s cabinet, has argued that the dual goals of destroying Hamas and securing hostages are mutually exclusive. He, along with other senior security officials, suggests that a negotiated cease-fire with Hamas may be the only realistic way to bring the approximately 115 Israeli hostages home safely. Hamas has made it clear that any cease-fire must include a complete withdrawal of Israeli forces from Gaza, a condition Netanyahu is reluctant to accept, preferring instead a temporary pause in hostilities.
This internal conflict highlights a broader debate within Israel about the path forward in Gaza. While Netanyahu’s hardline stance resonates with his base, there is growing concern among military and political leaders that a prolonged conflict without a clear strategy could lead to further instability and loss of life. As the situation in Gaza remains volatile, the Israeli government’s unity and decision-making are being tested like never before.
